Features from context, form wins; Exponence — proposal
Proposal:
- accept the principle of clarification No. 18: feature values come from context, and in a conflict the form wins;
- wait on
Exponencein MISC.
What exactly in mova.
- keep the "FEATS from the subject" normalization (
en::ud::agreement, The Mova dialect: a UD metadialect, treebanks, and converters) and give it a boundary: where the form is unambiguous, agreement does not override it. VBZ is alwaysSing|3. VBP is neverSing|3: the team are →Plur|3. Was is alwaysSing; - put gates
udnext.vbz-3sgandudnext.vbp-not-3sgon theenoutput and on silver data.
Why accept.
- This is already EWT practice:
- VBD and VBP get
Number/Personfrom the subject (VBDSing|33499, VBPPlur|32515…); - you and it get
Caseby position; - VBZ
Sing|3— 5655 of 5656 (the exception is a token with empty FEATS); - there is no VBP
Sing|3in the basic tree.
- VBD and VBP get
- Lossless: export to 2.18 changes nothing.
- What it guards against: the subject normalization must not override the form under semantic agreement (the team are, a number of people are). Otherwise it would produce a feature that is not in the standard.
Why wait on Exponence.
- There is no value set. Clarification No. 18 says directly: "We are not prepared to standardize the set of values without further community experimentation". There is only a pilot in French (
Exponence[Number]=Inherent). - #1233 is still open: "lexical" features on a/each/every and on modals.
- For English one split would be useful:
Number/Personon VBD/VBP — from context, on VBZ — from the form. But it is computable from XPOS, so there is no need to write it into MISC until there is a standard.
Check. udnext.vbz-3sg, udnext.vbp-not-3sg (Features from context and Exponence in MISC (universal, 2.19)). On EWT 2.18: 1 and 0 violations.
Origin. Features from context and Exponence in MISC (universal, 2.19); docs/changes.md#morphosyntactic-features; #1233.
Mova decides.
This page in Markdown → https://md.mova.elamur.ai/free/en/docs/dialects/mova/seeds/features-context/